When Hatred Is Excused as Youth: The Moral Weight of Adult Speech
Earlier this week, I came across an important story that reveals something deeply broken in the moral conversation of our time. The Prime Minister of the United Kingdom Keir Starmer, recently said he was “delighted” to welcome back to Britain Alaa Abd El-Fattah. El-Fattah an Egyptian-British activist, had been imprisoned in Egypt, and his release had long been championed by human-rights organizations. The controversy erupted when past social-media posts by Abd El-Fattah resurfaced recently. In these posts he praised the killing of “Zionists” which is indistinguishable from the celebration of violence against Jews. These were not comments made during adolescence, or in some distant, immature past. They were written when he was in his late twenties and early thirties, old enough to understand precisely what such words mean, and how such rhetoric has historically translated into real-world harm. The outrage that followed was predictable and justified. Words that celebrate viole...