The Supreme Court Got It Right

 Yesterday morning, the Supreme Court announced its decision in Fulton vs. City of Philadelphia, a case with significant ramifications for religious life in America. I believe this is one of the most important cases regarding religious rights and freedoms in years.

And once again, the Supreme Court got it right.

The issue in the case was again the clash between our society's need to root out discrimination in all of its forms, and freedom of religion and expression in all of its forms. As a religious minority which has relied on the benefits of religious freedom AND laws that prevent discrimination, the Jewish community has much at stake in this decision and others like it.  Our security and freedoms are, in large measure, tied to each of these values.  Which value, however will take precedence when society must choose between them?

Fulton vs. City of Philadelphia involved a local Catholic social services agency which had a contract to facilitate vetting for the placement of foster children and providing adoption services in Philadelphia for over a century. In 2018, the city of Philadelphia canceled its contract with CSS, citing their refusal, actually their policy, (which is of course based on Catholic doctrine and beliefs) against placing children with same sex couples. This was perceived as discrimination against members of the LBGTQ community, especially same sex couples, and initial court rulings favored the city of Philadelphia, which had cancelled their contract on the basis.  But yesterday morning, the Supreme Court announced in a unanimous decision that the city of Philadelphia could not bar CSS from screening potential foster parents.

I will leave it to you to review the various arguments and merits of this case. As I have explained on so many occasions, just as I am not a real doctor, I’m also not a real lawyer, so I’m probably not the person to explain it them to you. But what I can share with you is my real fear that growing secularization in our great nation is leading many people to conflate sincere and deeply held religious beliefs with bigotry. The abandonment of our Judeo-Christian heritage by so many does not ipso facto mean that there can be no principled opposition to same sex marriages or aspects of the LBGTQ legislative agenda. Whereas we do not want our civil society to discriminate, we must allow for religious belief to be exercised freely in this great nation. And when the two values clash, as they will continue to do in a society that seeks to uphold both values, we must not assume a default position that sincere, deeply held religious beliefs are evil or bigoted, and thus may be discarded on that mistaken basis.

I’d like to explain this in terms that perhaps more members of the congregation might understand. Imagine a situation where we need to hire a new custodian for the synagogue. Given the nature of the work that this position entails, this job would include service and activities on Shabbat that are forbidden to Jews.


If this were a job at CVS or Walgreens, those businesses must hire anyone that is qualified for the job. But the synagogue is allowed (actually, let’s not mince words - we have the right!) to limit that job to non-Jews. On one hand, you could argue that that is discriminatory. But our understanding of our religious obligations, and the freedom to pursue them must be protected, even though it does on some level potentially discriminate against a Jew interested in the position who does not follow or practice those Shabbat restrictions. I have warned the congregation for years, with full awareness of the possible negative ramifications, that we must always side with those arguing for the maximal expression of deeply held religious convictions.

Or let’s put it another way. Let’s imagine the synagogue is hiring a Rabbi, Cantor, or educational director. Is there anything wrong with the synagogue stating that the person who occupies those positions must be Jewish?  If future court rulings favor the important value of non-discrimination over religious freedoms guaranteed by the First Amendment, I fear that the answer might not be so self-evident.  And what a dangerous day for religious minorities that would be.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Jesus Was Not A Palestinian

Among the most pernicious aspects of Israel’s current war against Hamas has been the assault on truth, facts, and memory. As we have painfully learned, this brutal war is waged not only with military weapons, but also through an extensive disinformation campaign waged by Israel’s enemies, and their willing accomplices throughout the western world. We see this daily in irresponsible reporting in the media, the tolerance and even acceptance of antisemitic rhetoric and behavior on college campuses, and mouthed by politicians. We are told that Israel is a colonial enterprise, denying the 4000 year history of the Jewish people in the land of Israel. We were told that Arab and Muslim narratives regarding Israel must be accepted uncritically lest we be accused of racism and Islamophobia, while Jewish and Israeli narratives are subject to a level of scrutiny unparalleled in modern history. We are told regularly that Gaza is under Israeli occupation when the truth is that Israel withdrew
Read more

Jim Harbaugh Is No Hero

I’m not much of a college football fan. But I wanted to say something about the College Football Playoff championship game last Monday night, which saw the University of Michigan defeat Washington, 34-13. This tremendous victory was Michigan’s first national title since 1997. The Wolverines, as the Michigan football team is known, have a national following that numbers in the millions. They boast one of the premier sports programs in all of college sports. 38 former students are currently playing in the NFL.   The university has the largest stadium in the United States at 107,601seats, larger than any stadium used by an NFL team, and the third largest stadium in the world.   (By comparison, the largest NFL stadium, MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford NJ can seat 82,500.) They have sold out every game except one for the past 48 years.   The team deserves praise for their hard work, efforts, and stunning progress on the field.   Yet the Wolverines are not exactly a rags to riches sto
Read more

Now We Know

It has often been said -- were the Arab armies to lay down their arms for a day, nothing would happen. But if Israel were to do so, the response would be brutal and immediate. Sadly, now we know that these words were not just rhetoric or a talking point or an expression of moral superiority. Now we know that this is a statement of fact. The only thing that may have surprised observers was how immediate and how savage that truth would be.   We are experiencing one of the darkest periods in modern Jewish history. I cannot claim any greater insight or understanding than those reading my message today. But I would like to at least add some perspective and context that is often missing despite the sympathy demonstrated toward Israel at this moment.   The events of this past week are the largest single loss of Jewish life since the Holocaust. They recall the violence of the Pogroms in the late 19th and early 20th centuries that sent so many of our grandparents to these shores. They are r
Read more